Best Luxury Hotels in Shelter Island, United States from 219$/night

1-10 out of 10

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island

MapPrivate beach access0m

Waterfront dining with stunning views
Luxury spa offering diverse treatments
Heated outdoor pool for relaxation

Outdoor Pool
Full-Service Spa
Waterfront Dining

Historic resort offering diverse leisure activities

FromUS$ 334 /nightSelect

The Menhaden Hotel Greenport

MapCentral downtown Greenport200m

Rooftop bar with stunning views
Self-serve snack galley available
Chic, stylishly designed rooms

Rooftop bar
Bicycle rentals
Pet-friendly rooms

Boutique hotel combining coastal luxury and charm

FromUS$ 499 /nightSelect

Shelter Island House

MapOne block from Crescent Beach200m

Stylish rooms with spa bathrooms
Seasonal outdoor swimming pool
On-site restaurant and bar

Outdoor pool
On-site dining
Bicycle rentals

Boutique hotel with historic charm and modern luxury

FromUS$ 569 /nightSelect

The Chequit

MapClose to North Ferry300m

Dining at Red Maple restaurant
Complimentary breakfast offerings
Shared lounge and shops on-site

On-site Restaurant
Shared Lounge
Complimentary Breakfast

Charming hotel with delightful dining and shared spaces

FromUS$ 826 /nightSelect

Baron'S Cove

MapHistoric Sag Harbor village300m

Seasonal saltwater swimming pool
Harborside dining with local fare
Complimentary bike rentals available

Heated Pool
On-site Dining
Tennis Court

All-American resort offering harborside charm and amenities

FromUS$ 219 /nightSelect

Sunset Beach

MapIdyllic beach setting0m

Private beach access for guests
Unique food offerings available on-site
Free bicycle rentals for island exploration

On-site dining
Beach access
Bicycle rentals

Seaside resort with vibrant nightlife and dining options

FromUS$ 596 /nightSelect

American Beech Hotel

MapHistoric Sterling Square50m

Culinary excellence from a renowned restaurant
Dog-friendly accommodations available
Charming location in vibrant Sterling Square

On-site restaurant
Dog-friendly rooms
Cycling rentals

Boutique hotel offering unique dining and bar experiences

FromUS$ 514 /nightSelect

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

MapBeautiful waterfront settingon the beach

Private beach area for exclusive access
On-site restaurant with quality dining
Engaging nature activities offered nearby

Restaurant
Private beach
Bicycle rental

Charming beach resort with diverse recreational options

FromUS$ 420 /nightSelect

Hotel Moraine

MapStunning waterfront location200m

Inviting pool and beach area
On-site spa and massage services
Early check-in at 1:00pm

Outdoor pool
Private beach
Fitness centre

Hotel offering waterfront access and diverse leisure activities

FromUS$ 531 /nightSelect

Hamptons Style North Fork Chill 3 Bedroom 2 Night Minimum

MapClose to McCabe's Beach1.7km

Private pool with garden views
Barbecue facilities for outdoor grilling
On-site sauna for relaxation

Private pool
Picnic area
Indoor play area

Holiday home with private pool and barbecue amenities

Select

Price range for luxury hotels in Shelter Island

Explore a world of exceptional accommodations, from affordable stays to lavish retreats, with prices tailored to every luxury traveller's ideal getaway.

⬆️ The highest price

US$ 826

⬇️ The lowest price

US$ 219

💸 Average price for

4-star hotels

US$ 500

Luxury hotels in Shelter Island

Verified guest reviews from the past 12 months

Coastal Luxury Escape:

Baron'S Cove

Charming Boutique Retreat:

The Menhaden Hotel

Iconic Waterfront Getaway:

The Pridwin Hotel

Tranquil Beachside Bungalows:

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

Relaxed Island Vibes:

Sunset Beach

Modern Elegance and Comfort:

Hotel Moraine

Historic Charm Meets Modern Luxury:

The Chequit

Nature-Inspired Hideaway:

Shelter Island House

FAQs about luxury hotels in Shelter Island

Our answers will guide you to an effortless luxury experience

Which luxury hotels in Shelter Island offer unique views?

The Pridwin Hotel and Sunset Beach are known for their stunning waterfront views, perfect for enjoying sunsets over the bay.

Which luxury hotels are best for families in Shelter Island?

Baron'S Cove and The Chequit are excellent choices for families, offering spacious rooms and convenient access to nearby beaches and parks.

What are the top-rated luxury hotels based on guest reviews?

Top-rated properties include The Menhaden Hotel and American Beech Hotel, both praised for their service and amenities.

Which luxury hotels are located near popular landmarks in Shelter Island?

Hotel Moraine and Shelter Island House are located near popular spots like Crescent Beach and the Shelter Island Historical Society, making them convenient options.

What are the most affordable luxury hotel options in Shelter Island?

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows typically offers the most affordable rates starting around $200 per night during the off-peak season.

Luxury Hotel Insights for Shelter Island

This guide evaluates 9 luxury hotels in Shelter Island, U.S., offering essential details about pricing, peak seasons, and local fees to assist travelers in making informed accommodation choices.

Typical nightly rates range from $300 to $1,200 USD.

Shelter Island offers 9 luxury hotels.

Peak travel seasons are June to September.

Local hotel taxes average 10% of the nightly rate.

Most hotels are within 3 km of the Shelter Island Ferry.