Luxury Hotels in Shelter Island, United States
Exclusively curated and verified luxury accommodations in Shelter Island, United States
1-12 out of 12
Sort by:
high popularity
- Price: low to high
- Price: high to low
- Guest rating: high to low
- Popularity: high to low
MapPrivate beach access0m
- Waterfront dining with stunning views
- Luxury spa offering diverse treatments
- Heated outdoor pool for relaxation
- Outdoor Pool
- Full-Service Spa
- Waterfront Dining
Historic resort offering diverse leisure activities
FromUS$ 334
/nightSelect
MapCentral downtown Greenport200m
- Rooftop bar with stunning views
- Self-serve snack galley available
- Chic, stylishly designed rooms
- Rooftop bar
- Bicycle rentals
- Pet-friendly rooms
Boutique hotel combining coastal luxury and charm
FromUS$ 499
/nightSelect
MapOne block from Crescent Beach200m
- Stylish rooms with spa bathrooms
- Seasonal outdoor swimming pool
- On-site restaurant and bar
- Outdoor pool
- On-site dining
- Bicycle rentals
Boutique hotel with historic charm and modern luxury
FromUS$ 569
/nightSelect
MapClose to North Ferry300m
- Dining at Red Maple restaurant
- Complimentary breakfast offerings
- Shared lounge and shops on-site
- On-site Restaurant
- Shared Lounge
- Complimentary Breakfast
Charming hotel with delightful dining and shared spaces
FromUS$ 826
/nightSelect
MapHistoric Sag Harbor village300m
- Seasonal saltwater swimming pool
- Harborside dining with local fare
- Complimentary bike rentals available
- Heated Pool
- On-site Dining
- Tennis Court
All-American resort offering harborside charm and amenities
FromUS$ 219
/nightSelect
MapIdyllic beach setting0m
- Private beach access for guests
- Unique food offerings available on-site
- Free bicycle rentals for island exploration
- On-site dining
- Beach access
- Bicycle rentals
Seaside resort with vibrant nightlife and dining options
FromUS$ 596
/nightSelect
MapBeautiful waterfront settingon the beach
- Private beach area for exclusive access
- On-site restaurant with quality dining
- Engaging nature activities offered nearby
- Restaurant
- Private beach
- Bicycle rental
Charming beach resort with diverse recreational options
FromUS$ 720
/nightSelect
MapStunning waterfront location200m
- Inviting pool and beach area
- On-site spa and massage services
- Early check-in at 1:00pm
- Outdoor pool
- Private beach
- Fitness centre
Hotel offering waterfront access and diverse leisure activities
FromUS$ 1 117
/nightSelect
Beachside Waterview 2Br Condo W/ Pool In Greenport
MapBeachfront property access74km
- Private beach area available for relaxation
- Seasonal outdoor swimming pool on-site
- Two bedrooms with sea views and balcony
- Outdoor Pool
- Private Beach
- Barbecue Area
Beachside condo with pool and private beach access
FromUS$ 653
/nightSelect
Price range for luxury hotels in Shelter Island
Explore a world of exceptional accommodations, from affordable stays to lavish retreats, with prices tailored to every luxury traveller's ideal getaway.
⬆️ The highest price
US$ 1 117
⬇️ The lowest price
US$ 219
💸 Average price for
4-star hotels
US$ 593
Apartments
US$ 631
